# Should I Opt Out of AI Resume Screening? Your Rights

> Should I opt out of AI resume screening? What the opt-out changes, what it does not, your rights in NYC, Colorado and under the ADA, and how to ask.

Canonical: https://tryelip.ai/blog/ai-resume-screening-opt-out
Last updated: 2026-11-20

Published 2026-11-20.

Should I opt out of AI resume screening? Opt out when an AI match score is likely to undersell you: a career change, a gap, job titles that do not match the usual names, or a disability that affects how an automated test measures you. Stay in when your resume already lines up closely with the posting and you have no reason to think a keyword match will miss you. Either way, the opt-out is narrower than most people think. It usually removes one scoring step. It does not take your application out of the employer's system, and it does not switch off the screening questions.

## What the opt-out is

Most employers run applications through an applicant tracking system (ATS). Some turn on an AI feature inside it that compares your resume with the job and sorts applicants. The opt-out, where it exists, asks the employer to skip that AI step for you.

Greenhouse, a widely used ATS, documents how this works in its [Talent Matching help page](https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/41396009937307-Talent-Matching):

- Talent Matching compares candidates with criteria the employer sets, built from the job description and, if available, the interview scorecard. It sorts people into "Strong match", "Good match", "Partial match" and "Limited match".
- The employer chooses whether to offer an opt-out. If it does, a disclaimer on the application carries a link that lets you request manual, non-AI review for that job.
- If you opt out, you land in a group called "Needs manual review". Greenhouse says these candidates are "not evaluated by Talent Matching and must be assessed manually using your standard review process."
- The tool "does not automatically advance or reject candidates." Recruiters and hiring managers make those decisions either way.

Greenhouse's [AI principles page](https://www.greenhouse.com/ai-principles) says the same thing in general terms: AI can "inform, summarize and surface insight, but it is never the final decision-maker," and for Talent Matching "candidates can request manual review."

So in this setup, opting out changes how your application is sorted for the recruiter. It does not change who decides.

## What opting out does not change

People expect the opt-out to take software out of the process entirely. It does not.

- **Your application still sits in the ATS.** The system stores your resume and answers whatever you choose.
- **Screening questions still apply.** Greenhouse's [application rules](https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/203105595-Application-Rules-Overview) include auto-reject, which "uses custom application questions to screen and reject candidates based on their responses." That rule reads your answer to a question such as work authorization or location. It is separate from the AI match, so opting out of the match leaves it in place.
- **A person still has to reach you.** In Greenhouse's 2026 candidate survey, [81% of US candidates](https://www.greenhouse.com/newsroom/6-in-10-job-seekers-are-rethinking-how-they-write-to-avoid-sounding-like-ai-even-as-most-use-it-in-their-search) said they had been rejected from a job in the past year without ever speaking to anyone. Manual review does not mean someone reads every resume quickly.

## Where you have a legal right to ask

There is no single US law that gives every applicant an AI opt-out. A few places give you specific rights, and federal disability law covers accommodation everywhere.

### New York City: notice and a way to ask

New York City's Local Law 144 covers automated employment decision tools used to screen candidates for jobs located in the city. The [DCWP rules](https://rules.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/DCWP-NOA-for-Use-of-Automated-Employment-Decisionmaking-Tools-2.pdf) and the city's [FAQ](https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dca/downloads/pdf/about/DCWP-AEDT-FAQ.pdf) say:

- The employer must have a bias audit done before using the tool, and the audit summary must be public.
- Candidates who live in New York City must get notice at least 10 business days before the tool is used, in the job posting, by mail or email, or on the careers section of the employer's website.
- Under section 5-304 of the rules, the notice must include "instructions for how an individual can request an alternative selection process or a reasonable accommodation under other laws, if available."
- The same section adds: "Nothing in this subchapter requires an employer or employment agency to provide an alternative selection process."

In plain terms: in New York City you have a right to be told and a right to ask. The employer does not have to say yes to an alternative process. Complaints about a missing notice or audit go to 311 or the city's consumer and worker protection department, and discrimination claims go to the NYC Commission on Human Rights, according to the FAQ.

### Colorado: human review after an adverse decision

Colorado replaced its 2024 AI law in 2026. [SB 26-189](https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/sb26-189), signed on May 14, 2026, repeals and reenacts the earlier act around "automated decision-making technology" used to materially influence consequential decisions, and employment is one of them. The bill summary lists these rights for consumers:

- "Clear and conspicuous notice" at the point of interaction with a covered system.
- A plain-language description of the system's role within 30 days after an adverse outcome.
- A right to request "meaningful human review and reconsideration" after an adverse consequential decision.
- A right to ask for correction of "factually incorrect personal data" the system used.

Some duties start on January 1, 2027, and the attorney general must adopt rules on the adverse-outcome disclosure by that date. If you apply for jobs in Colorado, watch for these notices on applications from next year.

### California and Illinois

California's Civil Rights Council [regulations on automated-decision systems](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/2025/06/30/civil-rights-council-secures-approval-for-regulations-to-protect-against-employment-discrimination-related-to-artificial-intelligence/), in effect since October 1, 2025, say such a system may violate state law if it harms applicants or employees based on protected characteristics, and employers must keep the related records for at least four years. They do not create an opt-out button, but they make the employer answerable for what the tool does.

In Illinois, the state's ethics office [summarizes](https://oeig.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/oeig/publications/documents/Newsletter_March_19_2026.pdf) the change this way: the Human Rights Act was amended effective January 1, 2026, to prohibit AI in employment practices when it has the effect of discriminating on the basis of protected classes, and to require employers to disclose the use of AI for certain employment practices.

### Anywhere in the US: disability accommodation

The Americans with Disabilities Act applies whether or not a state has an AI law. [Section 12112(b)](https://www.ada.gov/law-and-regs/ada/) treats it as discrimination to deny a qualified applicant a job because the employer would need to make a reasonable accommodation, and to fail to give tests in a way that measures your skills rather than an impaired sensory, manual or speaking skill. If a disability affects how a timed assessment, a video interview or a game-based test measures you, ask for an accommodation. That request does not depend on the employer offering an AI opt-out.

## How to read a bias audit summary

If you are applying to a New York City job, you can check the tool before you decide. Under section 5-303 of the city's rules, the employer must post on the careers section of its website, or link to, the date of the most recent bias audit and a summary that includes the source of the data, the number of applicants, the selection or scoring rates, and the impact ratios for every category. The summary must stay up for at least six months after the employer last used the tool.

The rules define an impact ratio as the selection rate (or scoring rate) for one group divided by the rate for the most selected (or highest scoring) group. A ratio of 1.0 means a group is selected at the same rate as the top group. The further a group's ratio falls below 1.0, the less often the tool selects or scores that group highly compared with the top group. If the summary shows a low ratio for a group you belong to, that is a reasonable ground to ask for an alternative process.

For an example, Workday publishes one for its own use of HiredScore Spotlight on its [responsible AI page](https://www.workday.com/en-us/legal/responsible-ai-and-bias-mitigation.html). It covers US residents who applied to Workday in the greater New York City area from September 1, 2025 to February 28, 2026, across its five highest-volume job profiles, and states there is "no evidence of disparate impact based on the calculated impact ratios." An audit describes the data it was run on, so it cannot tell you how another employer's setup treats your application.

## Should you opt out? A quick way to decide

No employer or vendor we checked publishes callback rates for candidates who opt out, so treat any claim that opting out "hurts" or "helps" your odds as unproven. Decide on your own situation.

Lean toward opting out when:

1. You are changing careers and your past titles do not use the words in the posting.
2. You have a gap or a nonlinear history that a strict match might count against you.
3. Your best experience is described in terms a keyword match would miss, such as freelance, military or academic work.
4. A disability affects how an automated assessment measures you. Ask for an accommodation as well.
5. You applied before and your resume did not parse well, for example because it was a designed template.

Lean toward staying in when:

1. Your resume already uses the posting's own words for skills you really have.
2. You meet every required qualification and say so plainly on the first page.
3. The role gets heavy volume and you have no specific reason to expect a poor match.

Public opinion leans against AI deciding. In a [Pew Research Center survey](https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2023/04/20/ai-in-hiring-and-evaluating-workers-what-americans-think/) of 11,004 US adults, 71% opposed AI making final hiring decisions and 41% opposed AI reviewing job applications. That tells you how people feel. It says nothing about your odds with any one employer.

## How to ask for human review

1. Read the application page and the careers page for an AI notice. In New York City it has to be there 10 business days before use, and Greenhouse's version is a disclaimer with a link.
2. If there is a link or checkbox, use it before you submit.
3. If there is no link, email the contact named in the notice, or the recruiter, before or right after you apply.
4. Keep a copy of the notice, the job link and your request.
5. If you need an accommodation for a disability, say so in the same message and name what would help.

You can copy this message and edit the details:

> Subject: Request for manual review, [Job title], [Job ID]
> 
> Hello [Name],
> 
> I applied for the [Job title] role ([Job ID]) on [date]. Your application notice says an automated tool helps assess candidates for this role.
> 
> I would like my application to be reviewed by a person, without the automated assessment, if you offer an alternative process. [If relevant: I would also like to request a reasonable accommodation for [the assessment or interview step], because [one line on what you need].]
> 
> Thank you,
> [Your name]
> [Phone] | [Email]

## What helps either way

Opting out does not fix a resume that is hard to read. Whether a person or a tool reads it first, the same basics apply:

- Put each required qualification you meet in plain words near the top. Our guide to a [tailored resume](https://tryelip.ai/blog/tailored-resume) shows how to do that without inventing anything.
- Use a single-column layout that software can parse. The [ATS friendly resume template](https://tryelip.ai/blog/ats-friendly-resume-template) has a plain version you can copy.
- Answer screening questions truthfully and completely, since those rules run regardless of the AI step.
- Apply to fewer roles you fit well. Our [AI job search guide](https://tryelip.ai/blog/ai-job-search) explains why mass applications backfire.

If you want to see how the matching step works from the inside, read [how AI resume screening works](https://tryelip.ai/blog/ai-resume-screening). For the wider numbers on applications and rejections, see our [job search statistics](https://tryelip.ai/research/job-search-statistics).

For the bigger picture, read [what an AI career agent does](https://tryelip.ai/guides/ai-career-agent).

## Finding your next role

[Meet Elip](https://tryelip.ai/), an AI career agent. Add your resume and say what you want. Each morning it brings you a few jobs that fit, each with the reason. It rewrites your resume for each role, with your approval. It is free for candidates.

## Sources

- Greenhouse Support, "Talent Matching": [https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/41396009937307-Talent-Matching](https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/41396009937307-Talent-Matching)
- Greenhouse, "Our AI principles": [https://www.greenhouse.com/ai-principles](https://www.greenhouse.com/ai-principles)
- Greenhouse Support, "Application Rules Overview": [https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/203105595-Application-Rules-Overview](https://support.greenhouse.io/hc/en-us/articles/203105595-Application-Rules-Overview)
- Greenhouse, 2026 candidate survey release (October 20, 2026): [https://www.greenhouse.com/newsroom/6-in-10-job-seekers-are-rethinking-how-they-write-to-avoid-sounding-like-ai-even-as-most-use-it-in-their-search](https://www.greenhouse.com/newsroom/6-in-10-job-seekers-are-rethinking-how-they-write-to-avoid-sounding-like-ai-even-as-most-use-it-in-their-search)
- NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, rules on automated employment decision tools, section 5-304: [https://rules.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/DCWP-NOA-for-Use-of-Automated-Employment-Decisionmaking-Tools-2.pdf](https://rules.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/DCWP-NOA-for-Use-of-Automated-Employment-Decisionmaking-Tools-2.pdf)
- NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, "Automated Employment Decision Tools: Frequently Asked Questions": [https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dca/downloads/pdf/about/DCWP-AEDT-FAQ.pdf](https://www.nyc.gov/assets/dca/downloads/pdf/about/DCWP-AEDT-FAQ.pdf)
- Workday, "Responsible AI and Bias Mitigation for HiredScore Spotlight": [https://www.workday.com/en-us/legal/responsible-ai-and-bias-mitigation.html](https://www.workday.com/en-us/legal/responsible-ai-and-bias-mitigation.html)
- Colorado General Assembly, SB 26-189, "Automated Decision-Making Technology": [https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/sb26-189](https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/sb26-189)
- California Civil Rights Department, Civil Rights Council regulations on automated-decision systems (June 30, 2025): [https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/2025/06/30/civil-rights-council-secures-approval-for-regulations-to-protect-against-employment-discrimination-related-to-artificial-intelligence/](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/2025/06/30/civil-rights-council-secures-approval-for-regulations-to-protect-against-employment-discrimination-related-to-artificial-intelligence/)
- Illinois Office of Executive Inspector General, newsletter, March 19, 2026: [https://oeig.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/oeig/publications/documents/Newsletter\_March\_19\_2026.pdf](https://oeig.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/oeig/publications/documents/Newsletter_March_19_2026.pdf)
- Americans with Disabilities Act, Title I, 42 U.S.C. 12112(b) (ADA.gov): [https://www.ada.gov/law-and-regs/ada/](https://www.ada.gov/law-and-regs/ada/)
- Pew Research Center, "AI in Hiring and Evaluating Workers: What Americans Think" (April 20, 2023): [https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2023/04/20/ai-in-hiring-and-evaluating-workers-what-americans-think/](https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2023/04/20/ai-in-hiring-and-evaluating-workers-what-americans-think/)

## Frequently asked questions

### Should you opt out of AI resume screening?

Opt out when a keyword or match score is likely to undersell you: a career change, a gap, unusual job titles, or a disability that affects an automated test. Stay in when your resume already matches the posting closely. No employer or vendor publishes data showing that opting out raises or lowers your chances.

### Does opting out of AI screening hurt my chances?

There is no published evidence either way. In Greenhouse's documented setup, opted-out candidates go to a "Needs manual review" group and must be assessed through the employer's standard process. The risk is time: a manual queue depends on how quickly recruiters work through it.

### Can an employer refuse my request for an alternative process?

In New York City, yes. The rules require the notice to explain how to request an alternative process or an accommodation, but they also say nothing requires the employer to provide an alternative. A disability accommodation is different: under the ADA, the employer must make a reasonable accommodation unless it would impose an undue hardship.

### Will a human read my resume if I opt out?

Someone has to assess it for you to move forward, since the AI step is skipped. That does not guarantee a fast or full read. Screening questions with auto-reject rules still run, and a role can be filled before the manual queue is cleared.

### How do I know if a company uses AI to screen resumes?

Look for a notice in the job posting, on the application form or on the careers page. Employers covered by New York City's Local Law 144 must give one to city residents and publish a bias audit summary. Elsewhere there may be no notice, so you can ask the recruiter directly.

### Is AI resume screening legal?

Yes, but the employer remains responsible if the tool discriminates. New York City requires bias audits and notice, California's regulations apply anti-discrimination law to automated-decision systems, Illinois prohibits AI use that has a discriminatory effect, and Colorado's 2026 law adds notice and human review rights.

### What is NYC Local Law 144?

It is a New York City law on automated employment decision tools. Employers and employment agencies using such a tool to screen candidates for city jobs need a bias audit within the past year, a public summary of it, and notice to candidates who live in the city at least 10 business days before use.

## Related

- [All posts](https://tryelip.ai/blog)
